Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

The Bond ball mill grindability test: procedure, work index calculation and worked examples

The standard Bond ball mill grindability test: the 285-ball charge, the 700 cm³ feed, the 250% circulating load, and the Gbp and work index calculation, with worked examples.

· 8 minute read · By

The Bond ball mill work index is the basis on which most ball mills are sized. Installed power depends on it: an undersized motor prevents the plant from reaching its target throughput, and an oversized one wastes capital. The work index is measured in a laboratory test that Fred Bond standardised in the early 1960s and that commercial laboratories still run in essentially the same way.

The test grinds a sample in a small standard mill, screens out the fine material, tops the mill up with fresh ore and repeats the cycle until the mass of fines produced per cycle reaches a steady value. That value measures how readily the ore grinds, and Bond's equation converts it to the work index in kilowatt-hours per tonne, which is then scaled up to size the plant mill.

The test is simple to describe and easy to perform slightly incorrectly, and a small error in the work index becomes a large error in installed power. This article sets out the procedure, the calculation and the points that most often cause disputes over results.

The work index

Bond's third theory of comminution holds that the energy needed to grind an ore depends on the new crack length produced, which varies with the inverse square root of particle size. In practical form:

W=Wi(10P80−10F80)

where

W
specific grinding energy, on the same basis as the work index (kWh/t)
Wi
Bond ball mill work index (kWh/t)
P80
product size, 80% passing (µm)
F80
feed size, 80% passing (µm)

W is the specific energy, and F80 and P80 are the 80% passing sizes of the feed and product in microns. The work index, Wi, is the energy needed to reduce the ore from a very large size to 80% passing 100 µm, and a high work index indicates a hard ore. Because the equation applies over a range of sizes, a single test result allows the energy to be estimated for any feed and product size within the range the test represents.

Equipment and the 285-ball charge

The standard mill is 305 mm (12 in.) in diameter and 305 mm long, with rounded corners and a smooth lining without lifters, and rotates at 70 rpm. It requires a revolution counter and a door for charging and emptying.

The grinding charge is 285 steel balls with a total mass of 20,125 g. Bond's original size distribution, as reproduced by Arellano-Piña and co-authors, is:

Ball diameterNumber of balls
36.8 mm (1.45 in.)43
29.7 mm (1.17 in.)67
25.4 mm (1.00 in.)10
19.1 mm (0.75 in.)71
15.5 mm (0.61 in.)94
Total285
Bond standard ball charge43, 67, 10, 71 and 94 balls of 36.8, 29.7, 25.4, 19.1 and 15.5 mm: 285 balls, 20,125 g.025507510036.8 mm: 434336.8 mm29.7 mm: 676729.7 mm25.4 mm: 101025.4 mm19.1 mm: 717119.1 mm15.5 mm: 949415.5 mmNumber of balls
Bond's standard charge: 285 balls in five sizes with a total mass of 20,125 g.

Summaries that list only four sizes, or 90 balls in the smallest size, total fewer than 285 and should not be used. Some laboratories use a different five-size mix that still totals 285 balls and about 20.1 kg, so the charge in use should be confirmed with the laboratory and kept the same throughout a test programme. Balls wear, so the charge should be weighed regularly and worn balls replaced with new ones of the same size to restore the mass to 20,125 g without changing the count.

Sample preparation

About 10 kg of representative material is required per test. The sample is stage crushed to pass 3.35 mm (6 mesh), with screening between stages to avoid generating excess fines that would distort the result.

A riffled sub-sample is sized to obtain the feed F80 and the fraction already finer than the test sieve, U. A 1,000 cm³ graduated cylinder is then filled by shaking, and 700 cm³ is taken and weighed. This mass, M, is the fixed charge for every cycle.

The locked-cycle procedure

Bond locked-cycle testGrind, screen on the test sieve, remove undersize, top up with fresh feed, set next revolutions, repeat to steady state.Grind in Bond millR revolutionsScreen ontest sieveUndersizeweighed, removedOversize + fresh feedback to charge mass MSet next R for250% circulating loadrepeat until net g/revis steady (7–10 cycles)
Each cycle grinds the 700 cm³ charge, removes the fine product, replaces it with fresh feed and sets the revolutions for the next cycle.
  1. Select the closing sieve, P1, usually close to the product size of the plant grind, because the work index can change with grind size.
  2. For the first cycle, load the 700 cm³ charge and the balls and grind dry for 100 revolutions.
  3. Empty the mill, separate the balls, screen the whole charge on the test sieve and weigh the undersize.
  4. Return the oversize to the mill and add fresh, unsegregated feed equal in mass to the undersize removed, restoring the charge to M.
  5. Set the revolutions for the next cycle to produce the undersize required for a 250% circulating load, as calculated below.
  6. Repeat until the net grams of undersize per revolution no longer trend up or down, which usually takes 7 to 10 cycles.
  7. Size the undersize from the final cycles to obtain the product P80.
Net grams per revolution by cycleNet grams per revolution rises in early cycles then settles near 1.40; the last three average 1.40.1.21.31.41.51.612345678CycleNet undersize per revolution (g/rev)Gbp = average of last three = 1.40Net g/rev: 1 → 1.3Net g/rev: 2 → 1.5Net g/rev: 3 → 1.4Net g/rev: 4 → 1.4Net g/rev: 5 → 1.4Net g/rev: 6 → 1.4Net g/rev: 7 → 1.4Net g/rev: 8 → 1.4Net g/rev
The test runs until net grams per revolution stops trending. The average of the last three cycles is the grindability, Gbp. Illustrative figures.

The cycle calculations

A 250% circulating load means that the oversize returned to the mill is 2.5 times the undersize produced. Equivalently, the undersize at the end of each cycle should be M / 3.5.

Part of the undersize in each cycle was already present in the fresh feed, and only the remainder was produced by grinding. The net grams per revolution for cycle i is:

Gi=mu,i−mf,i·URi

where

Gi
net grams of undersize produced per revolution in cycle i (g/rev)
mu,i
mass of test-sieve undersize removed after cycle i (g)
mf,i
mass of fresh feed in the charge for cycle i (g); in cycle 1 this is the whole charge
U
fraction of the fresh feed already finer than the test sieve
Ri
mill revolutions in cycle i

For the next cycle, the fresh feed added equals the undersize just removed, and it contributes U of its own mass as fines. The revolutions required are:

Ri+1=M3.5−mu,i·UGi

where

Ri+1
revolutions for the next cycle
M
mass of the 700 cm³ test charge (g)
M3.5
undersize target for a 250% circulating load (g)

Worked example: setting the second cycle

Illustrative figures: the 700 cm³ charge weighs M = 1,250 g, and 12% of the fresh feed already passes the test sieve.

StepCalculationResult
Cycle 1 undersizemeasured after 100 revolutions280 g
Fines already in the feed1,250 × 0.12150 g
Net grams per revolution(280 − 150) / 1001.30 g/rev
Target undersize1,250 / 3.5357 g
Fines in the 280 g of new feed280 × 0.1233.6 g
Revolutions for cycle 2(357.1 − 33.6) / 1.30249

Work index calculation

The ball mill grindability, Gbp, is the average net grams per revolution over the last three cycles at equilibrium. Bond's equation then gives the work index:

Wi=44.5P10.23·Gbp0.82·(10P80−10F80)Wi=49.1P10.23·Gbp0.82·(10P80−10F80)

where

Wi
Bond ball mill work index: kWh per short ton with 44.5, kWh per metric tonne with 49.1
P1
aperture of the test (closing) sieve (µm)
Gbp
ball mill grindability: average net grams per revolution over the last three cycles (g/rev)
P80
80% passing size of the test-sieve undersize product (µm)
F80
80% passing size of the fresh feed (µm)

This gives kWh per short ton. For kWh per metric tonne, multiply by 1.1023, which is equivalent to replacing 44.5 with 49.1.

Example: with a 106 µm test sieve, Gbp = 1.40 g/rev, P80 = 82 µm and F80 = 2,200 µm:

Wi=44.51060.23×1.400.82×(1082−102200)Wi=13.0 kWh per short ton

The result is 13.0 kWh per short ton, or 14.3 kWh/t.

Mill power from the work index

The work index, in consistent units, is entered in Bond's equation with the plant feed and product sizes. For an ore of 14.3 kWh/t ground from F80 = 2,000 µm to P80 = 150 µm at a throughput of 300 t/h:

W=14.3×(10150−102000)=8.5 kWh/tPmill=W·Q=8.5 kWh/t×300 t/h≈2,540 kW

where

Pmill
mill power before efficiency factors (kW)
Q
dry solids throughput (t/h)

Designs then apply Rowland's efficiency factors for conditions that differ from Bond's reference case, such as mill diameter, feed size and fineness of grind. One of these factors is Bond's rule that dry grinding requires about 1.3 times the energy of wet grinding.

Common sources of error

The ball charge must always be 285 balls at 20,125 g. Too few balls, worn balls or a non-standard size mix changes the grinding rate. Crushing directly to 3.35 mm in a single pass produces excess fines, raises U and distorts the test, so the sample must be stage crushed.

A test stopped while the net grams per revolution are still rising or falling has not reached steady state. Units are a further source of error: reports differ in whether they quote kWh per short ton or per metric tonne, and a 10% error from units is easy to make and expensive in a mill.

A work index measured at one closing size may not hold at another, so the test sieve should correspond to the plant grind. When the available sample is finer than standard stage-crushed feed, the standard result can be biased; Nikolić and co-authors have published corrections for this case. Finally, hardness varies within an orebody, so each ore domain should be tested and the spread of results considered as well as the average.

The standard test requires about a shift of laboratory time per sample. For routine monitoring of plant streams, quicker comparative methods are available; see rapid work index estimates from plant samples.

Ajax includes crushing and grinding unit models for checking a circuit design before it is built. Saldora can hold work index results in a measurement set alongside throughput and mill power, so that plant performance can be compared at equal ore hardness.

Glossary

Ball mill
A rotating drum partly filled with steel balls that grind ore to a fine powder.
Work index (Wi)
The energy needed to grind an ore from a large size to 80% passing 100 µm, in kWh/t.
Grindability (Gbp)
Net grams of fine material produced per mill revolution at steady state in the Bond test.
Test (closing) sieve
The screen that defines 'fine enough' in the test; its aperture is P1.
Circulating load
Coarse material returned to the mill; 250% means 2.5 times the fine product.
Locked-cycle test
A repeated laboratory cycle that imitates a continuous closed grinding circuit.
F80, P80
Sizes that 80% of the feed and product pass through, in µm.
Short ton
2,000 lb, about 0.907 metric tonnes; Bond's original unit.
Efficiency factors
Rowland's corrections to Bond's equation for conditions that differ from the reference case.

Frequently asked questions

How long does a Bond ball mill test take?

Usually 7 to 10 grinding cycles, which amounts to more than a full working day per sample.

How much sample is required?

About 10 kg of representative ore.

Is the test run wet or dry?

Dry. Bond's rule is that dry grinding requires about 1.3 times the energy of wet grinding, and this is applied when sizing mills.

Why must the ball charge be exactly 285 balls?

The grinding rate depends on the charge. A different count, mass or size mix gives a different result.

Is the work index in metric tonnes or short tons?

Bond's equation with 44.5 gives kWh per short ton. Multiply by 1.1023, or use 49.1, for kWh per metric tonne.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Bond, F.C. (1961). Crushing and grinding calculations. Allis-Chalmers Publication 07R9235B.
  2. Bond, F.C. (1952). The third theory of comminution. Transactions AIME, Vol. 193, pp. 484–494.
  3. Arellano-Piña, R., Sanchez-Ramirez, E.A., Pérez-Garibay, R. and Gutiérrez-Pérez, V.H. (2023). Bond's work index estimation using non-standard ball mills. Physicochemical Problems of Mineral Processing, 59(6), 172458. Link
  4. Gharehgheshlagh, H.H. (2016). Kinetic grinding test approach to estimate the ball mill work index. Physicochemical Problems of Mineral Processing, 52(1), 342–352. Link
  5. Nikolić, V., Doll, A. and Trumić, M. (2022). A new methodology to obtain a corrected Bond ball mill work index valid with non-standard feed size. Minerals Engineering, 188, 107822. Link
  6. Nikolić, V. et al. (2025). Proposal of a method for calculating the Bond work index for samples with non-standard feed particle size distribution. Minerals, 15(4), 358. Link

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.