Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Slurry pipelines: deposit velocity, pipe size and pump power with Durand's equation

Selecting a slurry pipe size that keeps solids in suspension with Durand's deposit velocity, and calculating pump power, with a worked example.

· 5 minute read · By

A slurry is a mixture of water and rock particles. At sufficient velocity, turbulence keeps the particles in suspension and they travel with the water. If the flow slows, the coarser and denser particles settle to the bottom of the pipe and form a sliding bed, and eventually a stationary one. The effective bore narrows, friction rises, and the line can block completely.

Slurry pipes are therefore sized differently from water pipes. For water, a larger pipe always reduces friction and power. For a settling slurry, an oversized pipe allows the velocity to fall below the velocity at which solids deposit. The design objective is a pipe small enough to keep the velocity safely above that limit.

Slurry lines carry ore through every concentrator: mill discharge to cyclones, cyclone overflow to leach or flotation, and tailings to the storage facility. This article covers estimation of the deposit velocity, pipe size selection and pump power, and the conditions under which the simple method ceases to be reliable.

Slurry line designSlurry flow and properties, deposit velocity, choose pipe size, friction losses and static head, pump duty and power.Flow, SG,particle sizeDepositvelocity VLPick pipe:v above VLHead:static + frictionPumpduty, power
The order of a slurry pipeline calculation.

Durand's limit deposit velocity

VL=FL2gD(S−1)

where

VL
limit deposit velocity: below it, solids settle and form a bed in the pipe (m/s)
FL
Durand factor, read from charts for the particle size and solids concentration
g
gravitational acceleration, 9.81 m/s²
D
pipe inside diameter (m)
S
solids specific gravity

FL is read from Durand's charts, or from later correlations that refine them, for the particle size and the volume concentration of solids. It is typically about 1 to 1.5 for sand-sized particles at moderate concentration, and lower for fine particles. The value of 1.3 used below is for illustration only; the value for a particular slurry should be taken from the charts or from testwork.

Pipe size selection

Worked example: a cyclone feed line carries 664 m³/h of slurry (0.184 m³/s) with solids of SG 2.7 at 45% solids by mass, and FL = 1.3.

v=4QπD2P=ρmgQHη

where

v, Q
mean velocity in the pipe (m/s) and slurry flow (m³/s)
P
pump shaft power (W; divide by 1000 for kW)
ρm
slurry density (kg/m³)
H
total head the pump must deliver, in metres of slurry
η
pump efficiency on slurry (fraction)
Pipe inside diameterVelocity v (m/s)Deposit velocity VL (m/s)Assessment
200 mm5.873.36Safe, but high wear and friction
225 mm4.643.56Safe, with a margin of about 30%
250 mm3.763.75No margin: will settle at reduced flow
300 mm2.614.11Solids will settle

For the 225 mm pipe, v = 4 × 0.184 ÷ (π × 0.225²) = 4.64 m/s, and VL = 1.3 × √(2 × 9.81 × 0.225 × 1.7) = 3.56 m/s.

Velocity and deposit velocity against pipe sizeVelocity falls quickly as the pipe gets larger while the deposit velocity rises; they cross at about 250 mm. Smaller pipes keep solids moving.0246810150200250300350Pipe inside diameter (mm)Velocity (m/s)Velocity at 664 m³/hLimit deposit velocityPipe velocityDeposit velocity
For 664 m³/h of slurry with solids SG 2.7 and a Durand factor of 1.3. The pipe must run to the left of the crossing, with a margin. Illustrative figures.

The design velocity must remain above VL at the lowest flow the line will experience, not only at design flow; start-up, reduced throughput and flow lost through a partly closed valve must all be considered. Wear rises steeply with velocity, so the objective is an adequate margin rather than the highest possible velocity.

Pump power

The pump must supply the static lift plus the friction losses in the pipe and fittings. With a total head of 35 m of slurry, a slurry density of 1.395 t/m³ (1,395 kg/m³) and a pump efficiency of 70% on slurry:

P = 1,395 × 9.81 × 0.184 × 35 ÷ 0.70 = 126,000 W, or about 126 kW at the pump shaft.

Pump curves are published for water. Slurry reduces both the head a pump develops and its efficiency, by amounts that depend on particle size, density and concentration, and pump suppliers apply head and efficiency ratios for the slurry; their figures should be used for selection. Friction losses for settling slurries are also higher than for water at the same velocity, and are estimated with slurry correlations such as those in the references.

Limitations of Durand's method

Fine, concentrated slurries, such as thickened tailings or paste, behave as non-Newtonian fluids. Their particles do not settle quickly, and the design limit is the transition to laminar flow. They require rheology testing (yield stress and viscosity) and different design methods.

Very coarse or very dense particles may require specific testwork in a pipe loop. Long or inclined pipelines require checks for slack flow on downhill sections and for settling at shutdown, and drain points and flushing water form part of the design.

Operating practice

Pump discharge pressure and motor current should be trended, because a rising pressure at constant flow often indicates that a bed is forming. Lines should be flushed with water before shutdown so that solids do not settle in place. If throughput falls, water should be added or slurry recirculated to keep the flow above the minimum, rather than allowing the velocity to fall.

Glossary

Slurry
A mixture of solid particles and water, pumped as a fluid.
Limit deposit velocity
The velocity below which solids settle out and form a bed in a pipe.
Durand factor, F_L
An empirical factor in Durand's equation that depends on particle size and solids concentration.
Head
The height to which a pump can lift a fluid; also used for friction losses expressed as height.
Settling slurry
A slurry whose particles settle quickly when flow slows; most mill circuit slurries.
Non-Newtonian slurry
A slurry, usually fine and concentrated, whose resistance to flow depends on the shear rate.
Head ratio
The ratio of the head a pump develops on slurry to its head on water at the same flow and speed.

Frequently asked questions

How is the critical velocity of a slurry calculated?

With Durand's equation: V_L = F_L × √(2gD(S − 1)), where D is the pipe inside diameter in metres, S is the solids SG, and F_L is taken from Durand's charts for the particle size and concentration.

Why can a larger slurry pipe block more easily?

A larger pipe lowers the velocity for the same flow and raises the deposit velocity, so the slurry can fall below the velocity needed to keep the solids moving.

How is slurry pump power calculated?

Multiply the slurry density (kg/m³) by 9.81, the flow (m³/s) and the total head (m of slurry), then divide by the pump efficiency on slurry. Divide by 1,000 for kW.

Does Durand's equation apply to tailings paste?

No. Fine, concentrated slurries are non-Newtonian and require rheology testwork and different design methods.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Durand, R. (1953). Basic relationships of the transportation of solids in pipes: experimental research. Proceedings of the Minnesota International Hydraulics Convention.
  2. Wilson, K.C., Addie, G.R., Sellgren, A. and Clift, R. (2006). Slurry Transport Using Centrifugal Pumps, 3rd edition. Springer.
  3. Abulnaga, B.E. (2002). Slurry Systems Handbook. McGraw-Hill.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.