Run-of-mine ore can contain rocks a metre across, whereas a ball mill requires feed of about a centimetre. Crushers close this gap in stages, because no single machine can reduce metre-sized rock to centimetre size efficiently.
The primary crusher receives ore from the haul trucks, and its product is conveyed to a stockpile that keeps the rest of the plant operating when the primary crusher or the mine stops. Cone crushers then reduce the ore further, and a screen returns oversize material for another pass. The screen undersize is the mill feed.
Crushing circuit design rests on four calculations: the required rate of each crusher, the size reduction in each stage, the load circulating through the screen, and the stockpile capacity. This article covers each, with a worked example for a 2.5 Mt/a gold plant feeding a ball mill. The energy calculation, using the Bond crushing work index, is covered in Bond crushing work index and crusher energy.
The design crushing rate
The mill normally operates more than 90% of the time. The crushing plant operates less, because it stops for liner changes, blocked chutes and oversize rocks, and many plants crush only on day shift. The crushing plant must therefore crush at a higher rate than the mill consumes ore, and must refill the stockpile while it runs.
where
- design crushing rate (t/h)
- crushing plant utilisation: fraction of calendar hours the crushers actually run
- overall reduction ratio; , , are the ratios of each stage
- ,
- sizes that 80% of the feed and of the final product pass (mm)
Worked example: 2.5 Mt/a with the crushing plant operating 70% of the time requires 2,500,000 ÷ (8,760 × 0.70) = 408 t/h. The mill at 92% utilisation requires 2,500,000 ÷ (8,760 × 0.92) = 310 t/h, and the stockpile absorbs the difference. Utilisation figures should be taken from similar plants, because they vary widely with ore type, crusher type and shift pattern.
Reduction ratio and the number of stages
The reduction ratio of a crusher is its feed size divided by its product size, usually based on the 80% passing sizes. The overall ratio from run-of-mine ore to mill feed is the product of the stage ratios.
| Stage | Feed F80 (mm) | Product P80 (mm) | Reduction ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary (gyratory or jaw) | 500 | 125 | 4.0 |
| Secondary cone | 125 | 35 | 3.6 |
| Tertiary cone in closed circuit | 35 | 12 | 2.9 |
| Overall | 500 | 12 | 4.0 × 3.6 × 2.9 = 41.7 |
Each crusher can achieve only a limited reduction before it chokes, wears unevenly or produces excessive fines, so fine crushing for a ball mill normally requires three stages. A SAG mill circuit usually requires only a primary crusher, because the SAG mill accepts coarse feed. The reduction each crusher can achieve, and its product size at a given closed-side setting, are taken from the manufacturer's data for that machine and ore.
Closed-circuit screening and circulating load
A screen in closed circuit with the tertiary crusher guarantees the top size of the mill feed, but the crusher then treats the oversize in the new feed together with all the material the screen returns. Where the screen feed consists of new feed and crusher product, a mass balance gives the crusher throughput:
where
- crusher throughput in a closed circuit with the screen ahead of the crusher (t/h)
- new feed to the circuit, equal to the screen undersize product at steady state (t/h)
- screen efficiency: fraction of the undersize-sized material in the screen feed that actually passes the deck
- fraction of the new feed finer than the screen aperture
- fraction of the crusher product finer than the screen aperture
- circulating load: crusher recycle as a fraction of new feed
Worked example: 400 t/h of new feed, 40% of it already finer than the 12 mm aperture, a tertiary crusher product 55% finer than 12 mm, and a screen efficiency of 90%. The crusher throughput is 400 × (1 − 0.90 × 0.40) ÷ (0.90 × 0.55) = 517 t/h, a circulating load of 129%, and the screen must handle 400 + 517 = 917 t/h.
Two consequences follow. A worn screen deck or blinded apertures reduce the efficiency and increase the recycle rapidly: at 80% efficiency the crusher load in this example rises to 618 t/h. Conversely, a crusher that produces a finer product (larger p) reduces the recycle. Both measures cost less than a larger crusher.
Stockpile sizing: live and dead capacity
A conical stockpile provides inexpensive storage, but only part of it is live. Ore drains to the feeder from the crater that forms above it, and the slopes outside the crater remain in place unless a dozer pushes them in.
where
- volume of a conical stockpile (m³); multiply by bulk density for tonnes
- stockpile height (m)
- angle of repose of the ore (degrees from horizontal)
- draw-down angle: the slope of the crater that forms above a single feeder, usually steeper than
- live fraction: the share of the pile that flows out by gravity through one central feeder
Worked example: a 20 m high pile of ore with a 38° angle of repose and a bulk density of 1.8 t/m³ holds π × 20³ ÷ (3 × tan²38°) = 13,700 m³, or about 24,700 t. With a 48° draw-down angle, the live fraction is (0.781 ÷ (0.781 + 1.111))² = 0.17, so only about 4,200 t flows out by gravity, equivalent to 13.6 hours of mill feed at 310 t/h. The full pile would last 80 hours, but only with a dozer working it.
The 17% figure agrees with the commonly quoted live fraction for a conical pile with one outlet. Several feeders in line beneath an elongated pile give a higher live fraction. The angles depend on the ore, its moisture and its fines content, and should be measured where possible.
Design checklist
| Item | Design basis |
|---|---|
| Feed size | The largest rock the primary crusher must accept, from the mine's blasting and loading practice; the primary crusher gape must accommodate it |
| Ore properties | Crushing work index, abrasion index, moisture and clay content. Wet, sticky ore blinds screens and hangs up in chutes and bins |
| Utilisation | Realistic operating hours for the crushing plant, used for the design crushing rate |
| Stage ratios and settings | Manufacturer data for the selected machines, checked against the circulating load |
| Screen area | Sized for the closed-circuit load, not the new feed alone |
| Live storage | Hours of mill feed available by gravity, for the longest planned crusher stoppage |
| Dust and access | Dust collection at transfer points, and space to lift crusher components and change screen panels |
Glossary
- Primary crusher
- The first crusher, usually a gyratory or jaw crusher, which takes run-of-mine ore.
- Closed-side setting (CSS)
- The smallest gap between the crushing surfaces of a cone or jaw crusher; it largely sets the product size.
- Reduction ratio
- Feed size divided by product size, usually using 80% passing sizes.
- Utilisation
- The fraction of calendar time a machine actually runs.
- Closed circuit
- A crusher and screen arranged so that screen oversize returns to the crusher until it passes.
- Circulating load
- The recycled oversize as a fraction of new feed.
- Angle of repose
- The natural slope of a pile of loose ore.
- Live capacity
- The part of a stockpile or bin that flows out by gravity through the feeders.
Frequently asked questions
Why is the crushing plant larger than the mill requires?
It operates fewer hours. It must crush the annual tonnage in its own operating time and refill the stockpile while it runs.
How many crushing stages are required?
For a ball mill fed at about 10 to 15 mm, usually three, because each crusher can achieve only a limited reduction. A SAG mill normally requires only a primary crusher.
What controls the circulating load in a crushing circuit?
Screen efficiency and the proportion of crusher product finer than the screen aperture. Worn or blinded screen decks are a common cause of high recycle.
How much of a stockpile is usable?
With one feeder beneath a conical pile, roughly a sixth flows out by gravity. Additional feeders, an elongated pile or a dozer increase the usable proportion.
Discuss your plant with a metallurgist
Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.
Talk to a metallurgistReferences and further reading
- Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 6, Crushers.
- Bond, F.C. (1961). Crushing and grinding calculations. British Chemical Engineering, 6.
- 911 Metallurgist. Calculating stockpile capacity. Link
Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.