Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

Magnetic separation of iron ores: drum separators, WHIMS and the Davis tube test

Magnetic separator types, LIMS for magnetite and WHIMS for hematite, the magnetic force equation, and the Davis tube test with a worked example.

· 4 minute read · By

Magnetic separation exploits differences in the response of minerals to a magnetic field. Magnetite, the main ore mineral of many Western Australian iron ore projects, is strongly magnetic. Hematite is only weakly magnetic, and quartz is not attracted at all. These differences allow the valuable mineral to be removed from a stream of ground ore.

For magnetite, a rotating drum containing fixed magnets is sufficient: the magnetite is held to the drum shell and carried out of the slurry. Weakly magnetic minerals require much stronger forces, which are produced by placing steel plates or rods in a very strong field so that the field changes sharply over short distances.

This article covers the types of magnetic separator, the physics that determines which type a mineral requires, and the Davis tube test used to evaluate magnetite ores.

Separator types

SeparatorUsed forPrinciple
Wet low-intensity drum (LIMS)Magnetite in slurry; recovering ferrosilicon and magnetite media in dense media plantsFixed permanent magnets inside a rotating drum hold magnetic particles to the shell and lift them out of the slurry
Dry drum and belt separatorsCoarse magnetite, cobbing before grindingAs above, on dry crushed ore
Wet high-intensity (WHIMS) and high-gradient (HGMS)Hematite, ilmenite, removing iron-bearing minerals from industrial mineralsA matrix of grooved plates, rods or steel wool in a strong electromagnet field creates very steep local gradients that catch weakly magnetic particles
Wet low-intensity drum magnetic separatorSlurry flows under a rotating drum. Stationary magnets inside the drum hold magnetic particles against the shell and carry them up and over to the magnetics launder; non-magnetic particles stay in the slurry and leave as tailings.tankrotating drumfixed magnets inside,shell turnsfeed slurrymagnetics(concentrate)non-magnetics (tailings)
A wet low-intensity magnetic separator. Magnetite is held to the drum shell by the magnets and lifted out of the slurry; weakly magnetic and non-magnetic minerals pass under the drum.

Magnetic force and field gradient

F=χVμ0×BdBdx

where

F
magnetic force on a weakly magnetic particle (N)
χ
volume magnetic susceptibility of the particle (SI, dimensionless)
V
particle volume (m³)
μ0
permeability of free space, 4π × 10⁻⁷ T·m/A
B, dBdx
magnetic flux density (T) and its gradient (T/m); a separator needs both a strong field and a steep gradient

A uniform field, however strong, only aligns a particle; it does not pull it. The force arises from the change in field across the particle, which is why high-intensity separators fill the field with steel matrix elements, each sharp edge creating a steep local gradient. The force also scales with particle volume, so very fine weakly magnetic particles are difficult to capture while the hydrodynamic drag on them remains relatively large. Strongly magnetic minerals such as magnetite do not follow this simple equation, because their magnetisation saturates, and low fields are sufficient for them.

The Davis tube test

Davis tube testA ground sample is fed into a glass tube that oscillates between the poles of an electromagnet while water flows through; magnetic particles stay in the tube and non-magnetic particles wash out; both are dried, weighed and assayed.Grind sampleto target P80Davis tube:field, wash waterMags andnon-magsDry, weigh,assay Fe, SiO₂DTR andFe recoveryrepeat at several grind sizes to find the grind that gives the target concentrate grade
The Davis tube is the standard laboratory test for magnetite ores. Run at a series of grind sizes, it shows how fine the ore must be ground to reach a saleable concentrate grade.

A Davis tube is a glass tube that oscillates between the poles of an electromagnet while water flows through it. Magnetite remains trapped in the tube and non-magnetic particles are washed out. The magnetic fraction is then released, and both fractions are dried, weighed and assayed. Test conditions, including field strength, sample mass, wash water flow and test time, affect the result and should be fixed in a written procedure.

DTR=mmagsmfeed×100RFe=DTR×cFefFe

where

DTR
Davis tube recovery: mass of magnetic concentrate as a percentage of the test feed
mmags, mfeed
dry masses of the magnetic product and of the test feed (g)
cFe, fFe
iron grade of the magnetic concentrate and of the feed (%)
RFe
iron recovery to the magnetic concentrate (%)

Worked example: a 20.0 g sample of ore ground to the target size gives 7.2 g of magnetic concentrate. The DTR is 7.2 ÷ 20.0 × 100 = 36.0%. The feed assays 30.2% Fe and the concentrate 68.5% Fe, so the iron recovery is 36.0 × 68.5 ÷ 30.2 = 81.7%. The non-magnetic fraction, by difference, assays (30.2 − 0.36 × 68.5) ÷ 0.64 = 8.7% Fe. This is iron held in hematite, in silicates or in magnetite locked in gangue.

Application of the results

Repeating the test at several grind sizes produces a grind-grade curve. Concentrate grade rises as the ore is ground finer and the magnetite is liberated, and the target grind is the coarsest that meets the concentrate specification for Fe, SiO₂ and other impurities.

DTR on drill samples is used in resource estimation to forecast the concentrate tonnes that a magnetite resource will produce. Davis tube results on plant feed also provide a benchmark for the plant: a plant concentrate well below the Davis tube grade at the same grind indicates separator or circuit problems.

Where the ore allows it, dry or wet magnetic separation of coarse ore before fine grinding, known as cobbing, rejects barren material early and reduces grinding energy.

Glossary

Magnetite
Fe₃O₄, a strongly magnetic iron oxide.
Hematite
Fe₂O₃, a weakly magnetic iron oxide.
Magnetic susceptibility
How strongly a material is magnetised in an applied field.
Field gradient
How quickly the magnetic field strength changes with distance; it creates the pulling force.
LIMS
Low-intensity magnetic separator, normally a drum separator for magnetite.
WHIMS
Wet high-intensity magnetic separator, using a magnetised steel matrix to catch weakly magnetic particles.
Davis tube
A laboratory magnetic separator used to measure the magnetic fraction of a ground sample.
DTR
Davis tube recovery: the magnetic fraction's mass as a percentage of the feed.

Frequently asked questions

What is DTR in magnetite?

Davis tube recovery: the percentage of a ground sample's mass that the Davis tube recovers as magnetic concentrate.

Can a drum separator recover hematite?

Not effectively. Hematite is only weakly magnetic and requires the steep field gradients of high-intensity or high-gradient separators.

Why does the Davis tube give a higher grade than the plant?

The test is a near-ideal separation on a small sample. Plant separators treat variable feed at high rates, and the plant grind may differ from the test grind.

Why is the test run at several grind sizes?

Concentrate grade depends on liberation. The tests show how fine the ore must be ground to reach the product specification.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 13, Magnetic and electrical separation.

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.