Tiegel home Talk to a metallurgist

CIL and CIP gold circuits: choosing between them and tracing gold losses

The practical differences between carbon-in-leach and carbon-in-pulp, why preg-robbing ore favours CIL, and how a tank-by-tank survey separates leach losses from adsorption losses.

· 4 minute read · By

Most gold recovered from milled ore is dissolved in cyanide and then adsorbed onto activated carbon. The two common circuit arrangements differ in when the carbon is introduced. In carbon-in-pulp (CIP), leaching is completed in a separate train of tanks before carbon is added. In carbon-in-leach (CIL), carbon is present in the same tanks in which the gold is dissolving. The chemistry is the same in both, but the timing affects the treatment of preg-robbing ore, the number of tanks required and the amount of gold held in the circuit.

Common elements of both circuits

In both arrangements, ground ore is leached in agitated tanks with cyanide and oxygen, and gold dissolves as the aurocyanide complex, which is then adsorbed by granules of activated carbon. Interstage screens retain the carbon in each tank, and carbon is pumped upstream against the flow of pulp. Fresh carbon therefore contacts the lowest-grade solution at the tail of the train, and the most heavily loaded carbon is removed from the head tank. Loaded carbon is sent to elution and electrowinning, and the stripped carbon is regenerated in a kiln before it returns to the circuit.

Comparison of CIP and CIL

CIP and CIL tank arrangementsCIP has leach tanks followed by adsorption tanks with carbon; CIL has carbon in the leach tanks themselves.CIP: leach first, then adsorbLeach 1Leach 2Leach 3Ads 1Ads 2Ads 3Ads 4slurry flowcarbon moves upstreamCIL: carbon in the leachLeach 1CIL 2CIL 3CIL 4CIL 5CIL 6CIL 7slurry flowcarbon moves upstream
Shaded tanks hold carbon (dots). In both circuits carbon is pumped against the slurry flow and removed loaded from the first carbon tank. Illustrative figures.
CIPCIL
LeachingIn a separate leach train, before any carbonIn the same tanks as adsorption
TanksLeach tanks plus adsorption tanksOne train, often with one or more leach-only tanks ahead of it
Carbon in circuitAdsorption tanks onlyMost of the train, so a larger inventory
Preg-robbing oreDissolved gold is exposed to preg-robbing material before it reaches carbonCarbon competes for gold as soon as it dissolves
Gold held on carbonLower, because less carbon is heldHigher, because carbon is present throughout the train

Choosing between CIL and CIP

Preg-robbing ore is the main reason for choosing CIL. Where the ore contains carbonaceous material or other constituents that adsorb dissolved gold, activated carbon in the leach tanks recovers the gold before the ore can. Combining leaching and adsorption in one train also reduces the number of tanks and therefore the capital cost.

CIP keeps the carbon out of the leach. Less carbon is held in the circuit, less gold is tied up as inventory, and less carbon is exposed to attrition over a long residence time. CIP suits ores that are not preg-robbing, and plants where leaching and adsorption are better controlled separately.

Many plants use a hybrid arrangement, with one or two leach-only tanks ahead of a CIL train. Fleming and co-authors describe how leach and adsorption rates govern the design of both circuit types.

Sources of gold loss in tailings

Gold in the tailings comes from one of three sources, each with a different cause and remedy.

LossUsual causeItems to check
Undissolved gold in the solidsIncomplete leachingGrind, coarse or locked gold, cyanide, dissolved oxygen, residence time
Dissolved gold in the tailings solutionIncomplete adsorptionCarbon concentration, carbon activity, advance rate, fouling, short-circuiting
Gold on carbon finesCarbon breakdown and loss to tailingsAttrition, damaged interstage screens, carbon handling

To identify the source, sample every tank in the train on the same shift and measure gold in solution, gold in the solids and gold loading on carbon. Plotted side by side, the three profiles usually show quickly whether the loss is a leaching problem or an adsorption problem.

Gold in solution down a CIL trainIn a healthy train solution gold falls towards zero by the last tank; when carbon is not keeping up it stays high.0.00.20.40.60.81.01234567Tank numberGold in solution (mg/L)Healthy circuitCarbon not keeping upHealthy circuit: 1 → 0.9Healthy circuit: 2 → 0.5Healthy circuit: 3 → 0.2Healthy circuit: 4 → 0.1Healthy circuit: 5 → 0.0Healthy circuit: 6 → 0.0Healthy circuit: 7 → 0.0HealthyCarbon not keeping up: 1 → 0.9Carbon not keeping up: 2 → 0.7Carbon not keeping up: 3 → 0.6Carbon not keeping up: 4 → 0.5Carbon not keeping up: 5 → 0.4Carbon not keeping up: 6 → 0.3Carbon not keeping up: 7 → 0.3Carbon not keeping up
A tank-by-tank solution profile. Gold left in solution at the tail end points to an adsorption problem rather than a leach problem. Illustrative figures.

If gold in the solids falls slowly and remains high at the tail, leaching is incomplete. Check dissolved oxygen and cyanide in the first tanks, and the grind. Our article on dissolved oxygen in gold leaching covers the oxygen supply in more detail.

If gold in solution rises towards the tail instead of falling, adsorption is not keeping pace. Check the activity of regenerated carbon, the carbon concentration in each tank and the condition of the screens.

Ajax includes leach and adsorption unit models, so changes to a train can be tested on a model before they are made. Theseus takes a description of a recovery drop and returns ranked causes with the evidence for and against each.

Glossary

Slurry (pulp)
Finely ground ore mixed with water.
Cyanide leaching
Dissolving gold from ore in a dilute cyanide solution with oxygen.
Activated carbon
Porous carbon granules that adsorb dissolved gold from solution.
CIP (carbon-in-pulp)
Leaching first in separate tanks, then adsorbing gold onto carbon in a second set of tanks.
CIL (carbon-in-leach)
Leaching and adsorbing in the same tanks, with carbon present while gold dissolves.
Preg-robbing
When natural carbon or clay in the ore adsorbs dissolved gold and takes it to tailings.
Interstage screen
A screen that keeps carbon in its tank while slurry flows on.
Elution
Stripping gold off loaded carbon with hot caustic cyanide solution.
Carbon loading
The amount of gold held on carbon, in grams per tonne of carbon.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better, CIL or CIP?

Neither in general. CIL suits preg-robbing ore and needs fewer tanks. CIP holds less carbon and less gold in the circuit. Many plants combine one or two leach-only tanks with a CIL train.

Why is gold lost in the tailings solution?

Usually because the carbon cannot adsorb it quickly enough: too little carbon, carbon with poor activity, fouled carbon, or slurry short-circuiting a tank.

Why is undissolved gold left in the residue?

Leaching was incomplete. Common causes are coarse or locked gold, a coarser grind, low cyanide or dissolved oxygen, and insufficient residence time.

What is gold on carbon fines?

Gold held on carbon that has broken down into particles small enough to pass through the screens and leave with the tailings.

Discuss your plant with a metallurgist

Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.

Talk to a metallurgist

References and further reading

  1. Fleming, C.A., Mezei, A., Bourricaudy, E., Canizares, M. and Ashbury, M. (2011). Factors influencing the rate of gold cyanide leaching and adsorption on activated carbon, and their impact on the design of CIL and CIP circuits. Minerals Engineering, 24(6), 484–494. Link
  2. Marsden, J.O. and House, C.I. (2006). The Chemistry of Gold Extraction, 2nd edition. Society for Mining, Metallurgy and Exploration.
  3. Assessment of options for economic processing of preg-robbing gold ores. AusIMM World Gold 2007. Link

Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.