At the end of each month a processing plant must report the metal it received, the metal it produced and the metal it still holds, and these three figures should balance. The difference, when they do not, is unaccounted metal. The purpose of metal accounting is to keep it small, explain it and demonstrate that the figures are reliable.
The figures are used well beyond the plant, in company reports, royalty calculations, reconciliation with the mine and, for listed companies, public statements to investors.
This article covers the month-end calculations and the principles of good practice. Reconciliation factors and gold-in-circuit methods are covered in gold reconciliation and gold in circuit, and the balancing calculations in mass balance reconciliation.
Check-in, check-out and unaccounted metal
where
- metal into the plant, from feed tonnes and feed assays
- metal leaving: product sold or poured plus tailings
- increase in metal held in the plant, such as gold in circuit (negative if it fell)
Worked example, one month at a gold plant:
| Item | Basis | Gold (oz) |
|---|---|---|
| Check-in: mill feed | 250,000 dry t at 1.62 g/t (feed sampler) | 13,021 |
| Gold poured | Bullion, refinery-settled | 11,250 |
| Tailings | 250,000 t at 0.16 g/t (tails sampler) | 1,286 |
| Increase in gold in circuit | Survey at start and end of month | 240 |
| Unaccounted | 13,021 − (11,250 + 1,286 + 240) | 245 (1.9%) |
The calculated head is (11,250 + 1,286 + 240) × 31.1035 ÷ 250,000 = 1.59 g/t, 98.1% of the assayed 1.62 g/t. Recovery on the calculated head is (11,250 + 240) ÷ 12,776 = 89.9%, whereas on the assayed head it would be 88.2%. Sites must state the basis on which they report.
Assessment of unaccounted metal
Every figure in the balance carries error. The poured gold, weighed and assayed by a refinery, is usually the most precise; feed and tailings sampling, belt weighers and gold-in-circuit surveys are much less so. The precision of each is estimated, the estimates are combined, and the unaccounted metal is compared with the combined error. A difference well within it is noise. A difference outside it, or one with the same sign month after month, indicates a bias that must be located, such as a belt weigher out of calibration, a sampler that misses part of the stream, or an inventory that is not being measured correctly.
The AMIRA P754 Code of Practice
The AMIRA P754 Code of Practice for Metal Accounting is the industry reference for good practice. It is not mandatory, but many companies and auditors use it as the standard. Its principles include:
- accurate mass measurement and a component balance, with a check-in/check-out approach on final products;
- consistent, transparent and documented procedures that do not depend on one person;
- target accuracy levels for the principal measuring and sampling points;
- regular stockpile and inventory surveys, with documented assumptions;
- identifying and minimising bias;
- timely results, sign-off for any replaced or estimated data, reconciliation, and regular internal and external audit.
Month-end checklist
- Close off weigher totals and check calibrations and zero checks for the month.
- Confirm that all assays have been received and that standards, blanks and duplicates passed; see assay QAQC.
- Survey gold in circuit, stockpiles and any other inventory at the same cut-off time.
- Run the balance, compare check-in with check-out, and compare calculated with assayed head.
- Investigate, document and sign off any replaced or estimated data.
- Issue the report with the basis of each figure stated.
Glossary
- Metal accounting
- Measuring and reporting the metal received, produced and held by a plant over a period.
- Check-in
- Metal entering the plant, measured from feed tonnes and assays.
- Check-out
- Metal leaving the plant in products and tailings.
- Unaccounted metal
- Check-in minus check-out and the change in inventory.
- Calculated head
- Feed grade back-calculated from products, tailings and inventory change.
- Gold in circuit
- Gold held in the plant at a point in time, in solution, on carbon and in other inventories.
- AMIRA P754
- An industry code of practice for metal accounting.
- Bias
- A consistent error in one direction, as opposed to random error.
Frequently asked questions
What is unaccounted metal?
Check-in less check-out and the change in inventory. In the example, 13,021 oz in, 12,536 oz out and 240 oz added to inventory leave 245 oz, or 1.9%, unaccounted.
Is a 2% unaccounted difference acceptable?
It depends on the precision of the measurements. It should be compared with the combined error of feed sampling, weighing, tailings sampling and inventory surveys. A difference that always has the same sign suggests a bias.
Should recovery be reported on calculated or assayed head?
Either may be used, but the basis must be stated. The two differ by the unaccounted metal, which is why the basis matters.
Is the AMIRA P754 code mandatory?
No. It is a voluntary code of practice, but it is widely used by companies and auditors as the reference for good metal accounting.
Discuss your plant with a metallurgist
Tiegel is a Perth metallurgy company. We help with testwork, plant optimisation, metal accounting and investigations, and we build the Tiegel Suite software.
Talk to a metallurgistReferences and further reading
- Power, D.P. (2010). The application of the AMIRA P754 metal accounting code in the coal industry. Journal of the Southern African Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, 110, July 2010. Link
- Applying the AMIRA P754 Code of Practice for Metal Accounting. Metplant 2008, AusIMM. Link
- Wills, B.A. and Finch, J.A. (2016). Wills' Mineral Processing Technology, 8th edition. Butterworth-Heinemann. Chapter 3, Metallurgical accounting, control and simulation.
Worked examples and charts marked illustrative use invented figures, not data from any operation.